The Wicked Problem of Higher Education
We have all read, heard, and expressed our own views about the growing misalignment between the current resilient (STEM) Higher Education system and the contemporary needs. We have also all undertaken initiatives to reform, innovate, and adapt. Yet, the problem proved deep-seated, persistent, and immune to these efforts. On the one hand, the misalignments between today’s—and tomorrow’s—demands and the current system are much deeper than can be corrected by isolated efforts of curricular change or the adoption of new pedagogies. On the other hand, the robustness and resilience of the current educational system have enabled it to thwart attempts at more comprehensive reform.
The mismatch between what students, the economy, and the world need and what we are currently delivering has been extensively documented. We are still catering to a narrow profile of students in terms of socioeconomics, gender, ethnicity, and learning styles. Extensive efforts at diversifying have had very limited impact. We are still operating on the basis that faculty’s knowledge and expertise are our primary added value, even though knowledge has long turned into a ubiquitous and free commodity. Our curricular structures, contents, and delivery remain largely focused on producing uniformity, predictability, and conformity, even though the magnitude, complexity, and speed of changes we are facing put a premium on autonomy and innovation at all levels, not just high-level leadership positions. The academic institution is organized strictly around isolated disciplines, creating several impediments to cross-disciplinary pollination and collaborations. Similarly, students are expected to choose a single discipline as their focus and take a curriculum controlled almost exclusively by faculty from that discipline. This organization persists even though the challenges the world is facing are multifaceted and require cross-disciplinary knowledge and approaches.
Faculty and administrators have not been ignoring this chasm between what is and what should be. There is a growing number of mostly faculty-driven initiatives around the country and the world attempting to research and create alternative forward looking exemplars of STEM education. These exemplars are ambitious, innovative, and far-reaching in their potential impact. Most of them encounter systemic difficulties that take them by surprise and end up consuming much of their energy and resources. In his book “Wicked Problems: Problems Worth Solving,” Jon Kolke puts wicked problems’ difficulty in four categories: “incomplete or contradictory knowledge, the number of people and opinions involved, the large economic burden, and the interconnected nature of these problems with other problems.” All four categories apply to the transformation of Higher Education. We focus here on two broad complementary aspects: governance and culture with the premise that no solution is effective or viable unless it encompasses these two hand in hand.
Governance is the most overt manifestation of the values upheld and mission embraced by an institution. Governance is also the mechanism by which the system maintains stability and predictability; it embodies resilience and immunity to perturbations that can unsettle a highly optimized system. We mention here two values embedded in the current governance that run against some of the changes required. 1. The premise of knowledge as the core asset to be disseminated to students is manifest in the way faculty are prepared, assigned, and rewarded. Courses and curricula are prepared, reviewed, and approved through a deliberate slow and lengthy process. Only then they can be put in production. Their delivery is seen as a routine process of little scholarly value. Newly hired faculty are released from teaching so that they can prepare their new content, in isolation, again emphasizing the focus on content. This contrasts starkly with the way physicians are on-boarded, for example. Junior physicians are not left alone; they undergo extensive peer observation and peer feedback during their residency. Only then are they “left alone” with patients. Faculty, by and large, are rewarded through the production of new knowledge; skills in mentoring and teaching are assumed and undervalued. 2. Academia, more than any other institution, epitomizes a hierarchy of disciplines and values sanitized mono-disciplinary solitary work. The backbone of the academic administrative structure is an organization of faculty and administrators separated by disciplines. Curricular decisions, faculty hiring and promotion, and budgetary allocations are all done within the confines of disciplinary colleges and departments and promote competition over collaboration between the disciplines. Multi-disciplinary and transdisciplinary work takes place but remains hard to asses and reward.
The solutions seem self-evident: if we want to encourage a scholarly approach to teaching and learning, we simply change our reward system; if we want to promote collaboration, we simply change the budgetary model. This is where the wicked nature of the problem lies: these same artifacts that are problematic exist to safeguard values that cannot be shed so easily and so fast. As Robert Kegan and Lisa Laskov Leahy point in their book “Immunity to Change,” change is hard because the solution is often not technical (governance), but adaptive (cultural). Changing the technical processes alone often fails because unless we also address the root cause, the system’s immune system will kick in, resist change, and bring it back to its original state. The solution is often cultural; it requires a complete mindset shift from faculty and administrators. For faculty, we are the products of the system we are trying to change. Questioning the adequacy of the educational system and its underlying intellectual model threatens our identity and contributions. Yet, if we are to expect our graduates to demonstrate sufficient intellectual complexity, we must begin by learning and modeling this capacity, even as it feels uncomfortable. The persistent statements of alarms should serve as external and internal motivators to begin this mindset transformation. The magnitude of the problems the world is facing are a constant reminder of the limits of our current way of knowing, learning, and teaching. The wonder at new possibilities provide the intellectual fuel for this journey.
Wicked problems are hard but not impossible. The increasing number of initiatives around the country and abroad is indicative that there is a definite movement to change higher education.
This blog also appeared on May 1st 2015 at http://evolllution.com/opinions/wicked-problem-transforming-higher-education/
About the author
Claire Thorby @ on
Wicked has the all problem that was for the higher education this been good to read among the all parts that I have. If you was able to read some more details visit https://www.resumewriterslist.com/myperfectresume-com-review/ this was good to read the all aspect that was able to have among the formats on this it was good to read.
Reply Report abuse
franco taylor @ on
In the dynamic world of Mobile Legends, staying ahead and standing out has never been easier. Embrace the gaming revolution with Worst Injector Apk, and level up your MLBB experience by downloading the latest version now.
Reply Report abuse
Helenn mary @ on
Great post! I didn’t knowral of these resources and I’m going to go check them out now! build royale
Reply Report abuse
Hayden Roy @ on
nice
Reply Report abuse
coca coca mary mary @ on
Your sharing helps a lot for my work. I have learned a lot from your post.
fnaf
Reply Report abuse
braham bell @ on
Wobble Man I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging
Reply Report abuse
nosbshd nosbshd @ on — Edited @ on
Some tips related to writing services are here so if you think these are of some relevance with Paper Writing Pro then both of us will work this out for many others. We can look into this as this will be given by them to us as we will work this out for them soon.
Reply Report abuse
Hafiz Abdul Haleem @ on
Very interesting read. The current problems with Higher Education indeed draws attention to many societal and socio-economical issues. Being a part of a professional proofreading services Dubai agency, I'm aware of the 'wicked' problem you shed light on and how it is being ignored by the masses.
Reply Report abuse
Nida Bassam @ on
Yes, I totally agree with the wickedness of higher education. After learning for years one can't acquire much knowledge but then online resources are here to help. The smart ways to teach English is a rich source to learn faster and teach better.
Reply Report abuse
alisha oberoi @ on
gurgaon call girls
udaipur call girls
Reply Report abuse
seo expert @ on
Thank you for a absolutely interesting blog. What else may additionally I profit that handy of data written in this kind of unadulterated right of get right of entry to? Ive a engagement that i am profitably now humming in the back of inspiration to, and i’ve been at the see out for such data. best cricket betting
Reply Report abuse
seo expert @ on
This is such a nice useful resource that you are supplying and also you meet the price of it away for forgive. I hero reward seeing websites that take at the value of supplying a setting useful resource for set wandering. it’s far the primeval what goes on the order of comes almost about recurring. indian horse race
Reply Report abuse
Ander ton @ on
A new change for me when I read this article. I would like to share with you one more useful piece of information. Slope unblocked is a video game that combines 3D action elements. A world like Tron will undoubtedly allow you to throw a bowling ball in the wrong direction. As the game progresses, the speed of the ball increases, and you gain control of the ball at an increasing rate, similar to a roller coaster. It is not for the faint of heart. One of the most difficult games will put your ability to reflect to the test. Furthermore, slopes are a crazy 3D world where you must make the most of your time.
s down a slope.
Reply Report abuse
leo rasy @ on
It was no secret that higher education in the United States was a hot mess fnaf 2. As public universities became increasingly dependent on state funding, they began to hemorrhage money, leading to higher tuition costs and higher-than-ever student loan debt. basketbros
Reply Report abuse
Run sukamin 3 @ on
Spend some time playing crossword puzzles. I'm interested in finding out more because I have strong views about it. Would you please provide more details to your blog post? We will all actually gain from it.
Reply Report abuse
luu allbert @ on
A higher education system that’s out of reach for people from low-income backgrounds is part of the “stumble guys” of education. In this context, a “wicked problem” is one that is hard to solve, because it has no clear solution or an optimal solution. Cinenerdle
Reply Report abuse
yang tulo @ on
Well, simply beautiful, I heard this Snake io game today and it's on my favorites list, I feel something thank you!
Reply Report abuse
Mikoda Viklor @ on
They are classified as either mild or evil issues. Wicked difficulties are disorganized, unclear, unstable, tunnel rush poorly organized, and ambiguous. That's what I know after reading this book.
Reply Report abuse
zelda thehgd @ on
Our intellectual establishment is structured firmly on 2048 discrete disciplines, which puts a number of barriers in the way of cross-disciplinary collaborations. Similar to this, students are required to concentrate on a particular discipline and take courses within that discipline's faculty-controlled curriculum. Even though the problems the world is experiencing are complex and call for interdisciplinary methods and expertise, this organization continues to exist.
Reply Report abuse
York Damon @ on
This is such a helpful resource that you are providing, and you are giving it out at no cost. I admire websites that recognize the significance of giving a setting resource for location exploration. It is significantly more primitive than recurrent what goes on in the order of what comes next.
Reply Report abuse
Josh Mendes @ on
Many common examples of wicked problems come from public planning and policy. Global climate change, natural disasters, healthcare, the AIDS epidemic, pandemic influenza, international drug trafficking, nuclear weapons, uno online homelessness, and social injustice are examples of these.
Reply Report abuse
Mike Mike Rooney Rooney @ on
Thanks for sharing informative post. It is one of the best site that I have visited. Hope you will share more quality blog posts thank you. Spider Varse Leather Vest
Reply Report abuse
Anonymous @ on
Picture a world where the overwhelming specter of exam stress slowly dissipates, leaving behind a serene academic landscape. In this realm, our take my online gre exam for me service acts as a soothing balm, expertly alleviating worries and instilling unwavering calmness and confidence in your educational journey toward success.
Reply Report abuse
Priscilla W. Heuer @ on
Access SY0-701 dumps questions pdf exam mastery with our PDF dumps questions. Boost preparation with curated practice materials for Security+ certification, ensuring confidence and success in navigating complex cybersecurity concepts.
Reply Report abuse
Taylor Curran @ on
Find out what your real IQ is by taking the only iq test that changes based on your answers
Reply Report abuse
lena halminton @ on
That's amazing! They're exactly what I was looking for! I thank you all for sharing these wonderful and satisfying experiences with me! Now let's go with family and friends. Play game wordle unlimited online.
Reply Report abuse
kiviy kiviy @ on
Right? More of the song is revealed, up to a total of 16 seconds on heardle wordle.
Reply Report abuse
Abhaya isadoraabhaya Isadora @ on
Thank you for sharing this valuable knowledge; I think it will help everyone. Play game the baby in yellow free.
Reply Report abuse
William Gerorge @ on
Unlike traditional banking systems, there is limited consumer protection for cryptocurrency transactions. Chargebacks and refunds can be more challenging to manage. bitcoin sports betting sites
Reply Report abuse