Roadblocks to Creating a Competency-Based Program
Competency-based education is such an intuitive and appealing concept that once we consider it, we start wondering, “Why did we wait so long?”
In competency-based education, students earn a degree upon demonstrating competency in their chosen field of study rather than upon spending 120 credit hours in school. Under this model, students work hard to attain mastery at their own pace rather than being kept in lockstep with a fixed time schedule. Additionally, in a competency-based system, students are enabled to take risks and aim high with their academic pursuits rather than playing it safe to preserve their grade point average. Following on this, students earn credentials for any competency they master; they’re not penalized for attempting things for which they may not yet be ready. Finally, in a competency-based system the faculty coach, mentor and challenge; the students are in the driver’s seat setting the direction and speed of their learning.
With all of these established and potential benefits, it’s paradoxical that competency-based programs remain the exception rather than the rule.
Major forces maintain the status quo and resist the disruptions of major paradigm shifts. For anyone considering adopting a competency-based model, it’s important to be aware of the challenges and be prepared to conquer them.
These challenges are of three types: upstream challenges to actually build the new model of credentialing; downstream challenges to integrate the new model in the existing system and inner challenges in making sure a complete and authentic paradigm shift takes place. Over the course of these two articles, I will discuss each of these issues in detail.
1. Upstream Challenge: New Model Requires New Tools
The credit hour concept is hard to change because it’s embedded in every process, every tool and every policy within the academic system.
After all, students’ tuition is calculated based on credit hours; financial aid is assessed and continued based on credit hours; student transcripts record credit hours; programs and degrees are accredited and compared using credit hours; faculty loading and compensation are based on credit hours delivered. In fact the whole concept of credit hour was introduced as an administrative tool rather than a measure of educational attainment.
Moving away from the credit hour, or even changing it, requires full support and cooperation from all units within the academic institution: registrar, financial aid, faculty and administration. Accreditation, federal and state agencies are also increasingly aware of and interested in supporting emerging competency-based programs — whether full-fledged or as experimental sites.
At Purdue University, the competency-based degree developed and proposed by the Purdue Polytechnic Institute has managed these challenges thanks to a convergence of support and willingness to make drastic changes to make this work. The degree came about as a grassroots effort by a group of faculty with full support from the University president and board of trustees. Together, they’ve worked for a year in gaining support and collaboration from many strategic academic and administrative partners on campus. In order to mitigate the risks, the competency-based approach is restricted for now to a new degree. This pilot approach is consistent with the process of innovation in industry.
2. Downstream Challenge: New Currency Requires New Exchange Banks
No degree is an island, and for now competency-based degrees will live in a predominantly credit-based world.
On the surface, this is a simple mechanical process by which we map between courses and competencies. Competencies are, after all, nothing but a manifestation of the outcomes we aim to achieve in courses. Thanks to the many accreditation and assessment requirements academic curricula are subjected to, this information is widely documented. The outcomes of a calculus class, for example, can be packaged into three or four relatively independent and self-contained competencies. A student who receives an A grade in a calculus class can be assumed to have met every one of the four competencies. A student who can demonstrate mastery of all four competencies will be given credit for the calculus class.
Overall, a “currency conversion” system needs to be established so students can transfer into and from a competency-based system. It’s also necessary to enable graduates to apply to graduate schools and jobs that still require a numerical grade point average. This need will persist as long as we live in a predominantly credit-hour/grade system.
The competency-based currency is in fact a much more accurate and reliable currency because it reflects the learning attained by students rather than the quality or rigor of the class in which they have learned it. It therefore eliminates debates about whether College X’s calculus class is as good as College Y’s calculus class, or whether a B grade from College X is equivalent to a B grade in College Y.
The definition of competencies and the definition of what constitutes an acceptable mechanism to prove or document attainment become very important. The establishment of such a currency will require a considerable investment and will be a continuously evolving process. At the Purdue Polytechnic, we are engaging in a collective effort involving all units to define the currency and the conversion mechanism hand in hand and in partnership with all players.
3. Inward Challenge: New Language Requires New Thinking
One of the touted benefits of learning new languages is that they open the door to different lines of perception and thinking. Conversely, these benefits are conditional upon directly thinking in the new language rather than reasoning in the native language and translating to the new one.
The same goes for competencies. The full benefits of a competency-based system come from thinking, designing, delivering and assessing in terms of competencies. This requires that we relinquish counting variables we fully control (faculty time, student hours) and focus on things that are desired but not controlled (students’ learning). This is a cultural transformation and a leap of faith in the students’ intrinsic motivation and ability to take the lead role in their education. The role of the faculty becomes to support and coach the student; the students take an increasing role in defining the content and speed of their learning.
At the Purdue Polytechnic, the faculty who have designed the curriculum have spent half a year in faculty development, primarily through discussions and debates. The faculty development is an ongoing process. This is a very important paradigm shift.
Conclusion
Overall, there are infrastructural challenges and we need to make initial investments to address them. The most important investment of all is a mind shift and cultural transformation around the role of the students in learning and the role of faculty and administrators in supporting them.
This blog was published in two parts at Evollution
- Part 1 September 26 2014 https://polytechnic.purdue.edu/blog/roadblocks-creating-competency-based-program and
- Part 2 on October 2 2014 http://evolllution.com/programming/program_planning/roadblocks-creating-competency-based-program-part-2/
About the author
Kristy R. Dart @ on
Informative update here about the competency based education. Through this number of people able to get training and improve their technical skills. Trust me your sharing update on https://www.bestbritishwriter.com/ is quite motivational and would like to get enrolled in latest session.
Reply Report abuse
Jescie Emi Stein Guthrie @ on
thanks
Reply Report abuse
Den Benson @ on
Now Open! Welcome to Niagara Ontario, your gaming and entertainment destination in Niagara Falls!
Report abuse
charlie y hars @ on — Edited @ on
Amazing sharing content! looking forward for such other brilliant topics. This is help full for students. You will get more from https://laustan.com/ as well.
Reply Report abuse
coca coca mary mary @ on
I want to thank you for the hard work you have made in writing this article. Your creative writing ability has inspired me to start my own blog right now.
vex 3
Reply Report abuse
tijun donghua6 @ on
I have received user favorite neginmirsalehi
Reply Report abuse
Jones Elizabeth @ on
Thanks for your insight for that wonderful written piece. I’m glad I have taken the time to read this. champagnelady.co.uk
Reply Report abuse
Jones Elizabeth @ on
Much thanks for composing such an intriguing article on this point. This has truly made me think and I plan to peruse more.. deneme bonusu
Reply Report abuse
Anna Shetty @ on
Rich information, that's really good, I'm looking for it, thanks for sharing. wuxiaworld
Reply Report abuse
Joe Emma @ on
Thank you very much for this really helpful web post! I have read it with a great pleasure and have found a lot of important information for me there. word to pdf
Reply Report abuse
Sheikh Jabir @ on — Edited @ on
With challenges and competitions, some students try their best to do things in the best possible way to achieve the best and get the appreciation they truly deserve, however as a helper at professional CV writing services in UAE, I have seen that some students might find this extra pressure and can get affected by this big time, but yes, with proper help and encouragement who doesn't perform good in their own way.
Reply Report abuse
jack wisdon @ on
Hope you have to like the online this article get site for play euchre free online most of people can see this platform here thanks.
Reply Report abuse
Najwa Yaminah @ on
Competency education is truly valuable for this era and students also want to get a degree of competency-based education but they had to face some challenges in their dissertation and they prefer the dissertation writing service online where students get a great work by professional. I have read this stuff that's useful for those students who want to competency based education.
Reply Report abuse
big bear @ on
Do you want to impress your girlfriend’s father so bad you participate in a sing-off? Prove your worth in Friday Night Funkin and sing to the beat.
Feel the epic rap music battle and fight other with the power of rap music in friday night funkin game mobile edition!
Reply Report abuse
tijun donghua6 @ on
I have received user favorite
neginmirsalehi
Reply Report abuse
lily watson1v @ on
I adore this article for its well-researched content and great wording 1v1 battle
Reply Report abuse
John Smith @ on
I really appreciate this wonderful post.
ק××צ×Ŗ ××××
Reply Report abuse
jack bean @ on
Dramas coreanos Online Gratis, Doramas Sub Español, Capítulos Doramas, Descarga Doramas Completas, chinos, Tailandia, Japones, estreno dorama..
Reply Report abuse
John Smith @ on
Great job. Keep it up.
ק××צ×Ŗ ××××
Reply Report abuse
lu drake @ on
Roadblocks are just what they sound like: big, obvious things that prevent you from getting where you want to go nerdle. But a roadblock can also be something smaller--something that might not seem like a real obstacle at first glance. For example, maybe you're having trouble finding a volunteer coordinator because your organization is too new to have an established relationship with the right people at the right agencies. Octordle
Reply Report abuse
jack johnsonpo @ on
Got good information in your blog post I have read and seen it well I will share it with my friends You are a good writer keep publishing similar information continuously open your first io games lolbeans
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
I am extremely delighted with this web journal. It's a useful subject. It helps me all that much to take care of a few issues.
Copywriting Vancouver
Reply Report abuse
David Rogers @ on — Edited @ on
At first glance, it seems like a simple mechanical process by which we match courses and competencies. After all, competencies are nothing more than a manifestation of the outcomes we seek to achieve in courses. The information on https://studyessay.org/ A term paper at least once a year becomes a headache for every student. An English term paper is a double hassle because in addition to coherence and logical content, you need to spend a lot of time on spelling, punctuation, and everything else that makes a text flawless.
The first step in writing an English term paper is choosing a topic and finding the appropriate materials. Some students rush to libraries in search of primary sources, some prefer to search for literature on the Internet, and some delegate their task to professional essay writers.
The large number of digital libraries, freely available official documents and statistics, and examples of essays written by students make life much easier for today's students. Despite the fact that essay examples are only for reference, it is possible to benefit greatly from such help.
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
Your post has those facts which are not accessible from anywhere else.
Women's hats
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
Excellent article. The writing style which you have used in this article is very good and it made the article of better quality.
Charcuterie board
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
So lucky to come across your excellent blog. Your blog brings me a great deal of fun. Good luck with the site.
lean consulting
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
Your blog's content is very much apprecaible
gilgit weather
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.
DJ near me
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
I am extremely delighted with this web journal. It's a useful subject. It helps me all that much to take care of a few issues.
Earn Through Freelancing
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
This is truly the web service provider I was looking for!
online free quran classes
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
Thanks for the nice blog. It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog.
Daycare Langley
Reply Report abuse
su xeko @ on
This is something I've discussed with a friend. Run 3 is an addicting infinite runner game set in a futuristic universe in which you control a self-falling ball on a 3D track, combining old and new gameplay elements. A fast-paced game with some bizarre high-tech elements.
Reply Report abuse
Nancy Huerta @ on
ac
Reply Report abuse
mark scott @ on
maine lean six sigma curriculum high school students. Lean Six Sigma is a system with a team-oriented approach that is based on process improvement methodology. It is designed in a manner that helps organizations to eliminate and reduce the waste produced. This certification will help you improve the workplace environment suitable to customers’ needs.
Reply Report abuse
Overhead Door Pros @ on
it is very impressive and informative content good work keep it up
plunge pools jupiter
Reply Report abuse
Iram Akram @ on
I am extremely delighted with this web journal. It's a useful subject. It helps me all that much to take care of a few issues.
Job interview training
Reply Report abuse
giweleg643 giweleg643 @ on
Nice one
Muay Thai Gym Three Lakes
Reply Report abuse
Kristin hawthorne @ on
Competency based training is where the skills needed to do a job well are broken down into elements, and training is based focused on those individual skills.we are early in the shift from time-based to learning-based as the key milestones in education, or where “learning is constant, and time is the variable.” Contact us : Cochin airport taxi service
Reply Report abuse
dario hill @ on
Please continue to support Drift Hunters and join me in discovering the next exciting things the game has to offer!
Reply Report abuse
Theodore Evans @ on
I read a lot of things, and I thought the way you wrote to make it clear what you wanted to say was very good. I'm impressed, and I'd like to come back again sometime fnaf
Reply Report abuse
Annata Evan @ on
Identifying the competences required for each job role is a critical connections component of competency-based training. Creating competency standards and evaluation criteria. Employee performance is being evaluated.
Reply Report abuse
moto x3m @ on
Thanks for the information from your article moto x3m
Reply Report abuse
Anonymous @ on
Good step you have written of writing content relating to cooperate sense. Better yet good working skills and hope you write more of this soon. Georgia bulldogs varsity jacket
Reply Report abuse
lucy nancy @ on
The website mapquest directions is designed to be simple and easy to use, with no registration or payment required. The website is also constantly updated to bring you the most accurate and up-to-date information on traffic and maps. Visit mapquest directions today to discover its amazing features.
Reply Report abuse
Mike Mike Rooney Rooney @ on — Edited @ on
Your blog provided us with valuable information. I am looking forward to read more blog posts from here keep it up!! Miles Morales Varsity Jacket
Reply Report abuse
Anonymous @ on
Facing a mountain of exams? Fear not! Let our take my test online service be your sherpa. With our pros charting the path, those peak performances are within reach. Wave goodbye to altitude sickness and hello to summiting success. Strap in; we're scaling to the top together!
Reply Report abuse
lucy nancy @ on
This forum is amazing and there is a lot of useful content here driving directions. Companies can use this content to further improve the quality of disposable nitrile gloves although they have not received any complaints about them yet. However, there is still room for improvement.
Reply Report abuse
lucy nancy @ on
This forum is amazing and there is a lot of useful content here driving directions. Companies can use this content to further improve the quality of disposable nitrile gloves although they have not received any complaints about them yet. However, there is still room for improvement.
Reply Report abuse
Priscilla W. Heuer @ on
HQD Vapes offer an exceptional vaping experience with a variety of flavors. Discover satisfaction in every puff with the convenience and quality that define HQD, making each moment flavorful and enjoyable.
Reply Report abuse
Coby Brian @ on
Very nice, indeed.
Spinner Tools
Reply Report abuse
Lee Lenka @ on
This forum is amazing and there is a lot of useful content here driving directions. Companies can use this content to further improve the quality of disposable nitrile gloves although they have not received any complaints about them yet. However, there is still room for improvement.
Reply Report abuse
Debin Alsa @ on
Beyond their practical benefits, cowboy boots are also a fashion statement. They add a unique flair to any outfit, whether it's casual or formal attire. From classic western designs to modern interpretations mencowboyboots, there's a wide range of styles to choose from, allowing individuals to express their personal taste and sense of style.
Reply Report abuse
Debin Alsa @ on
Beyond their practical benefits, cowboy boots are also a fashion statement. They add a unique flair to any outfit, whether it's casual or formal attire. From classic western designs to modern interpretations mencowboyboots, there's a wide range of styles to choose from, allowing individuals to express their personal taste and sense of style.
Reply Report abuse
Jean Bundy @ on
A good and quality article, it's great to discover more about Papa's games with many interesting and exciting features.
Cancel Report abuse
Germ Eja @ on
The app’s user experience is further enhanced by its cross-platform support. AirBrush is available on multiple devices, including smartphones and tablets, allowing users to edit their content on the go. This flexibility is especially advantageous for busy professionals and travelers who need to access their editing tools from various locations. The synchronization across devices ensures that users can start editing on one device and continue seamlessly on another, without losing any progress https://airbrush.com/.
Reply Report abuse
APK PROFESSOR @ on
Free Download Latest Android Apps and Games.
Reply Report abuse
123 123movie4u Movies @ on
You can download and watch latest Bollywood, Punjabi and Hindi Dubbed Hollywood and Tamil Movies. https://www.123movie4u.com/
Reply Report abuse
Anna ann Cole @ on
The design encourages players to venture off the beaten path, rewarding curiosity with hidden treasures and lore. click now
Reply Report abuse
MrPc mrpcgame Game @ on
Download highly compressed free PC games and game torrents for free. Get access to a huge collection of Steam PC games with direct links. https://www.mrpcgame.com/
Reply Report abuse
1Pc Game @ on
Download highly compressed free PC games and game torrents for free. http://1pcgame.com/
Reply Report abuse
PcGame City @ on — Edited @ on
https://www.pcgamecity.com/Download highly compressed free PC games and game torrents for free. Get access to a huge collection of Steam PC games with direct links.
https://www.pcgamecity.com/
Reply Report abuse