Close

Blog

The Consciousness that Equitable Teaching Requires in STEM Classrooms

Dr. Dorinda Carter Andrews talk at Purdue DLRC on Friday, January 29, 2016

Posted by Mike Canning

 

Key takeaways

Society’s depictions of a scientist and of an engineer are too narrow. Help students to reach far beyond these depictions. Build students’ self-concept and self-efficacy in STEM work, so that they can see themselves in the disciplines that they are studying. Culture matters. Universities and disciplines typically operate under and promote the dominant culture’s codes. Equity is fairness and access to the same opportunities. I need to get to know my students as deeply as possible so I am truly including them. Inclusive teaching leads to learning that is meaningful, relevant, and accessible. It is important to contextualize what I teach. Reject deficit mindsets and promote growth mindsets. Do self-reflection, and do it critically. How does my own social identity shape my pedagogy? How do I learn more about what I don’t know? Where might I have implicit bias, where might I have expectancy bias, where are there stereotypes about individual students or groups of students? Video my classroom and me at work. Have someone observe me. Accountability is important if I am to grow in awareness and skill in becoming a more equitable STEM educator.

 

A summary of the talk in more detail

On January 29, 2016, a group of Purdue faculty and students were treated to a ninety-minute talk entitled “The Consciousness that Equitable Teaching Requires in STEM Classrooms” by Dr. Dorinda Carter Andrews. Dr. Andrews is Associate Professor in the Department of Teacher Education at Michigan State University, whose teaching and research is focused on race, culture, and equity in education. 

One of Dr. Carter Andrews’ first statements emphasized the need to help students see themselves in the disciplines they are studying, to help them imagine what they could be beyond the normative definitions and images of what the STEM fields are like. She cited examples where children were asked to draw what they thought a scientist looked like. Many drew pictures of white men – often, older white men – wearing lab coats. If we do a Google Image search on the word “scientist” these ideas are reinforced – most of the images are people in lab coats, mostly white men, with safety glasses, test tubes, and microscopes.

The Google Images for “engineer” largely bring up people with hard hats, holding construction drawings. Most are white men. Though we know that there are many white male scientists who work in laboratories and many engineers who work on buildings, these are very narrow depictions of the work of scientists and engineers across disciplines and around the world. 

We need to help our students imagine themselves working as a scientist or engineer or mathematician or technologist in ways that go far beyond these depictions. We need to build their self-concept and self-efficacy in STEM work, and help them to truly SEE themselves in the disciplines they are studying.

Dr. Carter Andrews asked us to consider three questions – Who am I? Who are my students? and Who are we together? She then focused on the concepts of culture and equality vs. equity. In broad terms, culture is a shared, symbolic system of values and traditions, encompassing relationships among people, worldviews, and behaviors. Culture is dynamic, not static, and is context-specific. STEM classrooms and departments have a culture that is also dynamic and context-specific. And this culture matters. Often, universities and disciplines operate under and promote the codes of the dominant culture. Dr. Carter Andrews noted that these codes are often “inherently racialized, classed, gendered, heterosexist, and homophobic spaces” where equity and fairness are not operating. She provided this quote from Alan Johnson (2008) on why culture matters and the challenges we face regarding diversity and its perceptions -  “The trouble around diversity isn’t just that people are different from one another. The trouble is that society is organized in ways that encourage people to use difference to include or exclude, to reward or punish, credit or discredit, elevate or oppress, value or devalue.”

While equality is sameness, equity connotes fairness; in other words, access to the same opportunities. Dr. Carter Andrews stressed that “outcomes should drive what needs to take place in the classroom.” Who are my students? A brief survey, given on the first day of class, or even better, online before the first day, will yield important information on who our students are, their backgrounds and their goals, and other important information that will help me shape my class. Relationships with my students are critical – the more I know them, the better equipped I will be to provide the access that each student needs to connect and thrive.

A slide entitled “Privilege, Power, Difference” showed a rendering of two students on ladders. One student was higher on his ladder than the other, indicating that he has a head start; in addition, the rungs on this student’s ladder were closer together than the others student’s, signifying that he has an easier climb than other student has. This is an image to keep in mind as I consider each my students, their backgrounds, and their aspirations.

Dr. Carter Andrews stressed the importance of critical self-reflection for the STEM educator. To help with self-reflection, she posed four questions that we should ask ourselves continually:

  1. How does my own social identity shape my pedagogy and teaching philosophy?
  2. How do I learn more about what I don’t know?
  3. What accountability measures do I (and hopefully my peers) have in place to ensure that I am dealing with these issues?
  4. How am I planning and implementing strategies to reach all learners?

She went on to describe implicit bias, expectancy bias, stereotype threat, microaggressions, and role congruity/incongruity, and how each of these can hinder equity in the classroom.  She urged the group to ask ourselves where we might harbor unconscious biases and where they might come from, and where there are implicit assumptions that could be influencing our judgments about our students and their capabilities.

 

Dr. Carter Andrews finished with suggested strategies. These included the following:

  • Integrate cultural relevance and diverse role models into the course curricula.
  • Build students’ self-concept, identity, and self-efficacy as it relates to STEM work. Some, perhaps many of our students are novices to STEM, and need us to introduce them to the different STEM fields in relevant ways, ways that are meaningful to them.
  • Contextualize STEM teaching to reach all students.
  • Emphasize to our students the importance of developing and practicing communication skills, which are increasingly called for in the STEM work world.
  • Encourage a growth mindset – that interest, commitment, and hard work matter and will help them to persevere when there are the inevitable setbacks.
  • Establish clear grading policies.
  • Videotape my class and observe my questions and my interactions with students
  • Ask a colleague to observe my class with a focus on how I am promoting or hindering equity.

 

We are grateful to Dr. Carter Andrews for the content and the encouragement to cultivate a consciousness that will lead to more equitable teaching in our STEM classrooms.  We at the TransSTEM Center want to continually be learning from people like Dr. Carter Andrews and furthering equity in each of the learning environments that we are involved with at Purdue and beyond Purdue.  

Comments on this entry

  1. Killian John

    老师知道如何处理班级和学生。https://essaypinglun.wordpress.com/ninjaessays-com-评论/ 分享他们对这个主题的观点,他们也有经验教师。

    Cancel Report abuse

    Replying to Killian John

    1. Den Benson

      Offers do not apply to employees of Rama Resort or Gateway Casinos & Entertainment Ltd. Rama Resort reserves the right to cancel or change any ...

      Reply Report abuse

      Replying to Den Benson

    2. Evelyn Mavilio

      Assignment Service UK gives you a chance to attain high grades by buy assignments online uk. Plagiarism free and well Referenced Paper Guaranteed.

      Reply Report abuse

      Replying to Evelyn Mavilio

    3. Evelyn Mavilio

      Assignment Service UK gives you a chance to attain high grades by buy assignments online uk. Plagiarism free and well Referenced Paper Guaranteed.

      Reply Report abuse

      Replying to Evelyn Mavilio

  2. Helenn mary

    very useful info, thank you for sharing with us!

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Helenn mary

  3. Jones Elizabeth

    This is extremely fascinating substance! I have completely delighted in perusing your focuses garage repair

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Jones Elizabeth

  4. Dennis Kemp

    Value in instruction implies that individual or social conditions, for example, sex, ethnic starting point or family foundation, are not snags to accomplishing instructive custom assignment help uk potential. The manner in which you accomplish Equality of Outcome is that somebody or some gathering in your association takes a tyrant position to drive results over the individual decisions as well as value of understudy candidates.

     

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Dennis Kemp

  5. Mark Scot

    Having a good supportive teacher is a pleasure for students because of there lots of things that is couldn't complete without teachers help and nowadays method of teaching is changing because of technology now a student can help them at any time from anywhere also the student can take custom essay service from that teachers or writers when they something.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Mark Scot

    1. jhon carry

      Are you struggling with your marketing assignments and in need of expert assistance? Look no further! Our premier marketing assignment help service is here to provide you with the support you need to excel in your coursework and achieve remarkable success.

      When it comes to marketing, we understand the complexities and challenges students often face. Crafting compelling marketing strategies, conducting thorough market research, and analyzing consumer behavior can be daunting tasks. That's why we have assembled a team of highly skilled and experienced marketing professionals who are dedicated to helping you overcome any hurdle you encounter.

      Reply Report abuse

      Replying to jhon carry

    2. Robert Gandell

      Native Assignment Help takes pride in offering comprehensive Nursing Assignment Help to nursing students around the world. We recognize that nursing is a noble and demanding profession, and we are here to support you in your academic pursuits. With our team of highly skilled nursing experts and academic writers, you can expect nothing but excellence when it comes to your nursing assignments. Our commitment to your success is unwavering. We ensure that your assignments are not just completed but are also rich in content, thoroughly researched, and in perfect alignment with your academic institution's guidelines. Our services cater to a wide spectrum of nursing subjects, including anatomy and physiology, healthcare ethics, pediatric nursing, and more.

      Reply Report abuse

      Replying to Robert Gandell

  6. honey bee

    Your progression coach has beat you with another last-minute assignment? Well, we’ve all been there. But what if we ask you that we have an another alternate idea for you? How about getting some free essay samples and switch your plans for the weekend? Law Essay Writer has no hidden reasons. We just want to assist the students populace and assistance them in creating original and well-written assignments on time. We’re also client centric in our method, so what’s really stopping you?

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to honey bee

  7. panoegads panoegads

    The post was very useful for me. The information was useful and interesting for me. I read on the https://essaysservicesreviews.com/ about this. Thanks for the info.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to panoegads panoegads

  8. angela byner

    Oh, great, your article provided me with useful information and a fresh perspective on the subject. Are you a big fan of Sonic games like me? 

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to angela byner

  9. vinci berry

    Do you like to eat seafood without knowing how to choose them? Please contact us Fresh Sea Food

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to vinci berry

  10. Robson Lee

    Sure, you could spend endless time tinkering with your MBA admission essay until you can’t stand the thought of it helpful site, but you can spare the time, effort, and mental torture and get some help!

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Robson Lee

  11. Phill Wagner

    The tension between what is, and what we dream of, is important. writemypapertoday  Not to discount what we have, but to hold onto that middle ground, because it's in there that the magic happens.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Phill Wagner

  12. ste phen

    An extensive game system is suitable for many different ages to slope game- Our game has received good quality reviews from a large number of users.
     

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to ste phen

  13. jack wisdon

    Bets update here you have to like this blog and see robux generator no verification there are many players exited to join this fun.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to jack wisdon

  14. alena official

    Corsair Mouse Harpoon Gaming — The Corsair Mouse M65 RGB Elite is CORSAIR's most advanced FPS gaming mouse so far, made around a top aluminum casing. Best Overall: Razer Basilisk V3 · Best Splurge: Logitech G502 Lightspeed · Best Wireless: Razer DeathAdder V2 Pro ·

    best corsair mouse for gaming in 2021

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to alena official

  15. lilliea dela

    It is useful information, I have researched it and saved it, will be interested in the next sharing, bubble shooter

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to lilliea dela

  16. mary coca

    The article gives me a lot of valuable information. Helped me learn many things.

    cookie clicker

     

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to mary coca

  17. jack bean

    OGWhatsApp is a modded version of WhatsApp which gives its users a clean, simple and free messaging service that is secure and reliable.

    og whatsapp APK

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to jack bean

  18. Jack Leo

    Your business needs a unique and memorable logo. Creating a logo is one of the first key branding decisions when building and launching your business. The logo is the cornerstone of the entire company, it is designed to remain in the memory of your customers for a long time, helping the company to develop.

    I have the necessary marketing education, advanced skills in graphic design, web design and development. Created hundreds of logos, dozens of brands, ranging from naming, brand books and corporate styles, some of which have been awarded at various competitions and are media. I will quickly and, most importantly, qualitatively develop the right logo for your business, corporate identity and other marketing materials.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Jack Leo

  19. Phil Reacher

    Want to know where you can get help writing an essay? With https://paperwritingservices.reviews/essay-box-review/ experts, you can have complete peace of mind. Our essay writing services include everything you expect to see

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Phil Reacher

  20. Alex James

    Hey, Ann Bessenbacher, This is Alex James from London and I'm a fiction ghostwriter UK. This is a very informational and helpful post on Teaching in Classrooms, will share it with other as well and hope to see more content in future thanks.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Alex James

  21. ash raf jame

    Fear Factor Khatron Ke Khiladi 13 Watch Online, Khatron Ke 
    Khiladi Season 13 Desi Tv Show, kkk 13 Online Episode Video.

    <a href="https://khatronkekhiladi13.com/">Khatron Ke Khiladi 13</a>

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to ash raf jame

  22. Muhammad Altaf

    https://yrkkhx.com/Welcome To yrkkhx.com To Visit Here For Watchin All Episodes
    Of Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai & other Hindi Dramas Free.

     

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Muhammad Altaf

  23. sadiqbuzdar sadiqbuzdar Saadibuzdar

    Bigg Boss is Indian Reality Tamil Language 
    Tv Show watch Here Free Live Streaming.

    <a href="https://bbt7live.com/">Bigg Boss Tamil 7 Live</a>

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to sadiqbuzdar sadiqbuzdar Saadibuzdar

  24. Muhammad Zain

    Watch Tamildhool Live Video Alll Latest Serial Online 
    Thirumagal Full Episodes Thirumagal Sun Tv Serials HD Video.

    <a href="https://thirumagall.cam/">Tamildhool Online</a>

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Muhammad Zain

  25. Ari Sha

    To serve a diversified readership, the online platform 
    Komikcast provides a large selection of digital manga and comics.

    <a href="https://komikcastapk.com/">Komikcast APK</a>

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Ari Sha

  26. Annata Evan

    Equity in science education necessitates providing all students with equitable opportunities to learn science and become engaged in science and engineering practices, as well as access to quality space, connections equipment, and teachers to support and motivate that learning and engagement, as well as adequate time spent on science.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Annata Evan

  27. zuhair abbas


    TamilDhool Serials Online in Tamil Language All
    Indian Dramas Dubbed in Tamil HD Video Downloads.
    https://tamildhoolz.cam/

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to zuhair abbas

  28. mar rontic

    I really appreciate the developer's investment in this game. Basketball Stars is both attractive with the stressful situation of pitching, as well as tactical and talented. This makes the game a great choice for basketball fans.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to mar rontic

  29. Joye Asmiranda

    The following are some of the advantages of fairness in STEM education: Addressing Cultural Issues: Racial discrimination and drift boss inequitable care are significant issues in STEM professions such as healthcare.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Joye Asmiranda

  30. Anonymous

    Ready to skyrocket your exam game? Our take my final exam for me service is the rocket fuel you've been missing. With our astronauts steering, you're on a one-way trip to the stars of success. Ignite your potential and let's blast off!

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Anonymous

  31. Hendrix Stephen

    I am very enjoyed this blog. It's an informative topic. It helps me very much to solve some problems.  x trench run

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Hendrix Stephen

  32. Priscilla W. Heuer

    Raz CA6000 Flavors redefine satisfaction with a burst of berry brilliance. Immerse yourself in a medley of sweet and tangy tastes, ensuring each draw is a flavorful journey worth savoring.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Priscilla W. Heuer

  33. Coby Brian

    Equitable teaching in STEM classrooms requires a broadened perspective of scientists and engineers, encouraging students to envision themselves in these roles. Fostering self-concept and self-efficacy in STEM is vital, considering the impact of culture on education. Embracing inclusive teaching, understanding students deeply, and promoting growth mindsets are key. Critical self-reflection, addressing biases, and seeking external observations contribute to becoming a more equitable STEM educator. For an insightful journey on this topic, click here. Also, explore the RACE THE SUN CHALLENGE EDITION for innovative approaches to teaching and learning in STEM.

    Reply Report abuse

    Replying to Coby Brian

Post a comment

Killian John @ on

老师知道如何处理班级和学生。https://essaypinglun.wordpress.com/ninjaessays-com-评论/ 分享他们对这个主题的观点,他们也有经验教师。

You must log in to post comments.

Please keep comments relevant to this entry.

Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted. URLs (starting with http://) or email addresses will automatically be linked.